Kirk vs. Picard

[Nusentinsaino]

Like this?

http://captkock.ytmnd.com/

p.s. lol i cant stop laughing at that one.

[MrFancypants]

Almost
But I actually meant Shatner's "professional" singing. http://www.kontraband.com/show/show....&searchstring=
He produced several CDs already.

One more singing Star Trek hero:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...=leonard+nimoy
He was on LSD and needed the money?

[Rue McDohl]

Picard defenders have failed to prove their facts thus Kirk wins.

Kirk singing>>>>Picard Singing.
Shirtless Kirk>>>>Preaching Picard.
Picard fans clearly do not fathom the power of Kirk.

[PICΔRЙ]

Hmmm, well i like all star trek, but i watch tng the most, so i gotta vote for picard. Kirk is great too, but picard would have to be my fav, thus most of my screen names in games,ims, etc. are PICΔRЙ

[CC_machine]

don't forget this picard's singing:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4327822273611416271&qicard+song

"the picard song".. i love that tune!!! this one is animated

oh and has kirk ever been assimilated by the borg and come back?
has kirk ever been trapped inside the holodeck?
has kirk ever saved the ship from a virus that infected the entire ship? (i don't actually know on this one.. has he?)

[fett321]

Picard all the way. Kirk was a great captain, but the majority of his decisions were based on the shoot first, see if there are any survivors, shoot them, then forget about asking questions and make assumptions instead. Picard tends to study the situation and then make a smart choice. He had no problem destroying the Borg cube. Don't forget that Picard had a doctor who was much better looking than bones. Mind you, Scotty is the best engineer hands down. Tough call.

[DarkTau]

But seriously, Kirk kicks arse. And you really have to understand that Kirk didn't really have the luxury of studying every problem, and for most of the problems Kirk had, the Answer was indeed to shoot.

[enigma123456789]

My vote cancels your non-vote if you dont vote you cancel your own opinion!
the BORG have the perfect vote your assimilated into the collective. you will make a good drone!

[Anlushac11]

IIRC in one of the movies (or was it from TNG episode with Spock on Romulus?) where Kirk is referred to using "Cowboy Diplomacy".

I go with Picard just casue I like TNG better. I actually hated Picard for first season or two of TNG and he grew to be my favorite Trek Captain.


But I think Kirk proved his Diplomatic skills in "The Undiscovered Country" and Picard also had his share of female admirers.

In combat I think the best Trek commander was Sisko followed closely by Kirk. Next up I would prefer Riker.

[Fez Boy]

Smooth-headedness ftw.

Picard all the way.