Is your starship in need of maintenance or does your crew need some R & R? Dock here and discuss anything related to the TV series and the films. Please do not discuss anything related to Star Trek games.
You post like the poll has ended. Its only been up for 2 hours, and its going into the weekend. It'll reach 20 more posts today easy.
Agreed, I only posted a couple of hours ago as Monster_user has pointed out. I will continue to watch this to see what kinds of varying opinions we can get.
she's pretty damn determined, wont be swayed away from her opinion, wont compromise unless neccessary, and isnt afraid to use her weapons (unlike Picard)
Xavier to Storm: "You of all people know how fast the weather can change..."
I'm currently going with Kirk. I'm gonna wait a while before voting, as I really want to vote for the ECH.
Robert April, don't have a clue who he was... Christopher Pike on the other hand... Harriman who? The Enterprise-B Captain perhaps? Barely remembered Garret from the Ente-C.
If Riker's gonna be up there, why not the legendary Hikaru Sulu? Captain Spock? Captain Montgomery Scott? What about the Captain Deckers? Matthew and his son William... Or Captain Hu Lin Radison? Wait, she's not canon.
You're right, I completely forgot Spock and Decker!
My intent was to get all who captained an Enterprise mentioned:
Robert April commanded the Enterprise on her first five-year voyage. The only known picture of him is actually a very young Gene Roddenberry in an old Starfleet uniform
Christopher Pike we should all know from The Menagerie as Enterprise' second captain.
John Harriman, as you correctly guessed, captained the Enterprise-B. Little is known of him or his ship's missions, short of their brief appearance at the beginning of Generations.
Rachel Garrett, who commanded the Enterprise-C, is better remembered, both for the mention her ship receives in the defence of Narenda III, as well as it's appearance in Yesterday's Enterprise and the establishment of Sela's heritage in Redemption.
Riker makes the list merely because All Good Things established him to have taken command of the Enterprise-D following Picard's retirement in that timeline (whether or not you believe it depends on which canon you choose to follow).
Matt Decker commanded the Constellation, not Enterprise. Will was an omission on my part.
Scotty isn't known to have ever held a command of his own (at least, not in Starfleet), and as such wasn't on my list.
Sulu was, to anyone's best knowledge, a fine captain. But Enterprise Excelsior was not.
At any rate, that was my line of thought in offering my (two short!) list of other candidates who failed to receive mention. No sense in listing every Starfleet captain, now is there?
Scotty did get the Genolan, in the TNG episode where the Enterprise gets trapped inside the Dyson sphere...
i still dont see why more people arent going with Janeway...she was better in all aspects from Picard... good diplomatic skills (she had a treaty with the Borg!), not afraid and do some hand-to-hand combat herself, and wasnt afraid to fire her weapons
Xavier to Storm: "You of all people know how fast the weather can change..."
He showed great command ability. I liked the fact that he was willing to take on the Borg cube and bring down Locutus, even tho it was Picard . . . I found that admirable instead of what I thought was going to happen, that they wouldn't attack it and just try to save the captain . . . instead they did both
He had the maneuvers down, as shown in Insurrection, he could think of unique solutions to a problem and execute it perfectly . . . . and my favorite part was to my recolection neither Janeway, nor Picard (which were my number 2, and number 3 choices) ever physically did anything, but often Riker just said, "I'll take it from here ensign" and took over the console. I found that awesome that he would actually get into the action rather than just sit and watch from his cushy little lazy boy . . . .
Kirk for me, everyone. Mainly for his combat prowess both hand to hand and in the command chair. Although Kirk did his share of negotiating as well. Balance of Terror has to be one of my favorite episodes of all time. None of the other captains can "get" the women like Kirk can either. Favorite character in Star Trek(captain or otherwise) is Spock.
None of the other captains can "get" the women like Kirk can either
Riker does and let's not forget that Data banged the entire Borg collective, so B4, with those memories and abilities, could out 'do' Kirk in an instant
Ok people, lets try to remember that this thread is about captains from Star Trek. I've already had to remove a couple of posts by people that insist on posting about captains that have nothing to do with the Star Trek franchise. Please stay on topic.
Last edited by Guyver; February 5th, 2005 at 03:54 PM.
ok, the best captain was Sisko. How can you guys not see that? He is the only one who could actually fight and he was loved by the Bajorans and respected by Humans.
I just love how he could beat the hell out of a Jem Hadar....
God, you people
Janeway pwn3d them all.
She took a borg and made it an individiual again,
She wanted the peaceful way but wasn't afraid to get out there and fight either.
On top of it all she was a woman and still thouroughly respected as much as any guy.
Rock on Janeway.
Like a sigh piercing the moon,
It shines white, and scatters red.
This site is part of the Defy Media Gaming network
The best serving of video game culture, since 2001. Whether you're looking for news, reviews, walkthroughs, or the biggest collection of PC gaming files on the planet, Game Front has you covered. We also make no illusions about gaming: it's supposed to be fun. Browse gaming galleries, humor lists, and honest, short-form reporting. Game on!
Starbase 42 
Re: Who's your favorite captain? 
Linear Mode
