Notices

Go Back   FileFront Forums > Main Forums > The Pub > History and Warfare

Remember Me?

History and Warfare
Discussion of past events, military and warfare.

View Poll Results: Who has the best APC/IFV?
USA M2A3 M3A3 Bradley 4 36.36%
USA AAVP7A1 0 0%
British FV510 Warrior 3 27.27%
German Marder 1A3 1 9.09%
US-Canadian-Swiss Stryker/LAV/Coyote-Grizzly/Pirahna 1 9.09%
Russian BTR-90 1 9.09%
Russian BMP-3 5 45.45%
Chinese ZBD97 0 0%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 11. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old October 18th, 2007   #1
I would die without GF
 
Anlushac11's Avatar
 
Join Date: April 28th, 2003
Location: Babylon 5
Status: Available
15,517 posts, 41 likes.
Rep Power: 0
Anlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexeh
Default Who has the best APC/IFV?

We have done tanks and aircraft best of, but I dont think we have ever done a "Best of APC" discussion. And well..Im at work and bored.

Ok here are the contenders.

M2A3/M3A3 BFV (Bradley Fighting Vehicle)

USMC AAVP7A1

British FV 510 Warrior

German Marder 1A3

USA/USMC/Canadian/Swiss Stryker/LAV-25/Coyote-Grizzly/MOWAG Pirahna

Russian BTR-90

Russian BMP-3

Chinese ZBD97
Anlushac11 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old October 19th, 2007   #2
I would die without GF
 
Anlushac11's Avatar
 
Join Date: April 28th, 2003
Location: Babylon 5
Status: Available
15,517 posts, 41 likes.
Rep Power: 0
Anlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexeh
Default

My vote is for the BMP-3

It is fairly well armored, low profile, has a 100mm low pressure gun, good for fire support roles and has a ATGM for anti-tank.

My primary requirement is amphibious, decent armor, can do fire support well, and can engage tanks if it has to, not that it would want to.
Anlushac11 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old October 19th, 2007   #3
The Bad
 
MrFancypants's Avatar
 
Join Date: December 7th, 2003
Location: Germany
Status: Available
16,165 posts, 808 likes.
Rep Power: 50
MrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limitMrFancypants knows no limit
Default

Well, I don't really know so much about APCs, but I think Germany is replacing the Marder with a new APC, the Puma. This new Puma is apparently rather large and difficult to airlift (you need one plane to transport the vehicle and another to transport additional modular armor).


MrFancypants is offline   Reply With Quote
Old October 19th, 2007   #4
SCHOFIELD DID 4/30
 
Red Menace's Avatar
 
Join Date: August 10th, 2004
Location: Bear Flag Republic
Status: Sleeping
8,952 posts, 1561 likes.
Rep Power: 37
Red Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finestRed Menace is Gaming Forums’ finest
Default

Does the BMP-3 still hold extra fuel in the rear doors like the BMP-2 did? If so, you won't get me anywhere near it.


The best APC in my opinion is the Merkava, well it is kinda an APC. But of the choices, probably the BTR-90. It's fairly well armoured, pretty fast, eight wheel drive, holds as many men as the BMP-3, longer operational distance and is now being fitted with the same 100mm gun.
Red Menace is offline   Reply With Quote
Old October 19th, 2007   #5
Ultima ratio regum
 
Roaming East's Avatar
 
Join Date: November 6th, 2005
Location: Inverted prone position
Status: Sexy
4,709 posts, 97 likes.
Rep Power: 28
Roaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super Moderator
Send a message via Yahoo to Roaming East
Default

Gonna have to side with the BMP3. Has an autocannon for support, plenty of HE capability and has excellent agility because of its tracks. Turn radius on wheeled platforms is sometimes not ideal like in urban environments.

CANNON, n. An instrument employed in the rectification of national boundaries.
- Ambrose Bierce
Roaming East is offline   Reply With Quote
Old October 19th, 2007   #6
Arrrr!
 
Huffardo's Avatar
 
Join Date: November 29th, 2003
Location: Finland
Status: Crazy
3,882 posts, 57 likes.
Rep Power: 30
Huffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as RevengeHuffardo is almost as leet as Revenge
Default

I voted for the BMP-3, but I since I know little to nothing about IFVs I just might have chosen the CV90 if it was on the list.
For a wheeled vehicle the Patria AMV ought to be good enough (even though I irrationally prefer the old Pasi), them crazy Poles, Croatians, Slovenians and South Africans bought it.


Last edited by Huffardo; October 19th, 2007 at 02:42 PM.
Huffardo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old November 8th, 2007   #7
If you ain't Cav, you ain't...
Best Thread
 
EO Violation's Avatar
 
Join Date: October 5th, 2007
Location: Not Afghanistan
Status: Available
1,833 posts, 27 likes.
Rep Power: 20
EO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admiration
Default

US M3 Bradley CFV, but I'm probably a little biased... To say the least.

The 25mm Sabot rounds are enough to kill a T-55 at the proper range, TOW-IIs rip up armor like it's wet paper. Not only that, but the electronics carried by this little ditty sure as hell outclass whatever the BMP-3 has.

Though, in truth, the M3 CFV is a scouting vehicle, and not an APC (it only carries a two man scout team) or IFV.

Anlushac, I fail to see why armor is all that important in an APC. Fact of the matter is, if a tank-caliber cannon hits any APC, it is going to die. No matter what type of shell is being fired. What is most crucial in an APC is it's ability to remain unseen, as well as move at the pace of the tanks it will be fighting alongside as part of a mechanized battle.
EO Violation is offline   Reply With Quote
Old November 8th, 2007   #8
Ultima ratio regum
 
Roaming East's Avatar
 
Join Date: November 6th, 2005
Location: Inverted prone position
Status: Sexy
4,709 posts, 97 likes.
Rep Power: 28
Roaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super Moderator
Send a message via Yahoo to Roaming East
Default

Armor is important because next to the AK47, the RPG7 in its various warheads is as ubiquitous on the battlefield as blood and sweat. Any vehicle not able to withstand repeated strikes from light AT weapons is a bad vehicle to ride into battle. The Bradley, for all its vaunted abilities was still able to be knocked out by this cheap widely available threat. So they started putting cages around them, good idea, just beats up on the poor things transmission because of the added weight.

CANNON, n. An instrument employed in the rectification of national boundaries.
- Ambrose Bierce
Roaming East is offline   Reply With Quote
Old November 9th, 2007   #9
If you ain't Cav, you ain't...
Best Thread
 
EO Violation's Avatar
 
Join Date: October 5th, 2007
Location: Not Afghanistan
Status: Available
1,833 posts, 27 likes.
Rep Power: 20
EO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admirationEO Violation is worthy of your admiration
Default

The Bradley defends against weapons like this this with ERA. Mine was equipped with quite a bit of ERA. Saved my ass twice too.

Here's an M2 with ERA:


However, I will give you this much. The aluminum structure of the Bradley does pretty much dissolve in the face of HEAT warheads.

Besides, I'll be damned if a BMP-3 simply shakes off a Javelin, or even AT4, hit.
EO Violation is offline   Reply With Quote
Old November 9th, 2007   #10
Ultima ratio regum
 
Roaming East's Avatar
 
Join Date: November 6th, 2005
Location: Inverted prone position
Status: Sexy
4,709 posts, 97 likes.
Rep Power: 28
Roaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super ModeratorRoaming East is as cool as a Super Moderator
Send a message via Yahoo to Roaming East
Default

You'd be surprised. Modern ERA has been proven to defeat DU rod style projectiles Such as the Abrams 120mm M829. This is protection for weapons that penetrate up to 550mm of RHA. At best, an AT4 can do about 420mm and thats with explosive, not concussive force so shooting at a target that is rolling around in ERA is very spotty with the AT4. The Javelin, being a dedicated MBT killer with top attack abilities of course does not suffer this penalty. Two different classes of weapons entirely.

CANNON, n. An instrument employed in the rectification of national boundaries.
- Ambrose Bierce
Roaming East is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT -7.







   
 





This site is part of the Defy Media Gaming network

The best serving of video game culture, since 2001. Whether you're looking for news, reviews, walkthroughs, or the biggest collection of PC gaming files on the planet, Game Front has you covered. We also make no illusions about gaming: it's supposed to be fun. Browse gaming galleries, humor lists, and honest, short-form reporting. Game on!

FileFront Forums - Terms of Service - Top
Theme Selection
Copyright © 2002-2016 Game Front. All rights reserved. Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Forum Theme by Danny King (FileTrekker), Sheepeep & Graeme(rs)
RSS Feed Widget by FeedWind