Notices

Go Back   FileFront Forums > The Games! > Battlefield Series > Battlefield Mod: Forgotten Hope > FH2 Suggestions

Remember Me?

FH2 Suggestions
Do you have a suggestion for the future release of FH2? Post it here!

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old January 31st, 2005   #1
Lo, I am Mudra, za emo soldat!
Brigadier General
 
Von Mudra's Avatar
 
Join Date: September 25th, 2004
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, California
Status: depressed
6,754 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 31
Von Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admiration
Send a message via AIM to Von Mudra
Default 20mm shell needs some power.

Now, I noticed a while ago that, although they have made the 20mm shell make a purty expolsion and all, it still has no shrapnel. I tried it out in single player, and yep, I can hit right at the feet of a soldier, and they take no damage. This should be fixed in .67. It should be like the 88 and 40mm shell, it should wipe infy off the map, and be a great house clearer. Also, the same should be fixed on the 20mm AA, plus the 20mm AA should have that proximity expolsion too, as they did use proximity fuses on the ground 20mms.


Last edited by Von Mudra; January 31st, 2005 at 07:39 PM.
Von Mudra is offline   Reply With Quote
Old January 31st, 2005   #2
Master of Kittens
 
Sputty's Avatar
 
Join Date: January 13th, 2004
Status: Available
970 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 25
Sputty is a n00b
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

40mm and 88mm were greatly reduced in power in HE rounds, or at least it looks like they were so 20mm really should be noticeably weaker and they are
Sputty is offline   Reply With Quote
Old January 31st, 2005   #3
Lo, I am Mudra, za emo soldat!
Brigadier General
 
Von Mudra's Avatar
 
Join Date: September 25th, 2004
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, California
Status: depressed
6,754 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 31
Von Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admirationVon Mudra is worthy of your admiration
Send a message via AIM to Von Mudra
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

Yeah, well, that ain't very realistic, yes? And we aren't talking just small HE capability of the 20mm here, I am saying I can pump 20 rounds of HE right next to a guy, and he won't die, or take any damage. THIS IS NOT REALISM! THe 20mm should be able to kill just by landing a few feet from a guy. It is basically a small grenade. When you put 10 of them inot a room, and don't kill the guy inside because none of the shells actually hit HIM it is not very realistic.

Von Mudra is offline   Reply With Quote
Old January 31st, 2005   #4
DiCE/EA: Ambiguously Gay Duo
Council Member
 
striderx2048's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 16th, 2002
Status: Available
2,106 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 31
striderx2048 is a n00b
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

depends if fh makes the shells AP or HE.

"Ask them, US and Brits didn’t do squat in WW2, it was won by the Soviet all by themselves versus the entire Germans Army and they did it while standing on one leg and with a arm tied behind their back. Western Europe, North Africa, Italy were all side shows" -unknown poster
striderx2048 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 1st, 2005   #5
FH tester
 
MkH^'s Avatar
 
Join Date: September 24th, 2003
Location: Finland
Status: Just posting
2,355 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 28
MkH^ has been known to help peopleMkH^ has been known to help people
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

Well, they explode so that'd indicate they are HE.

MkH^ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 1st, 2005   #6
Major Disinformation
 
Major Hartmann's Avatar
 
Join Date: April 27th, 2003
Location: Behind a Battleaxe
Status: Available
2,374 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 29
Major Hartmann should make some friends
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Von Mudra
Now, I noticed a while ago that, although they have made the 20mm shell make a purty expolsion and all, it still has no shrapnel. I tried it out in single player, and yep, I can hit right at the feet of a soldier, and they take no damage. This should be fixed in .67. It should be like the 88 and 40mm shell, it should wipe infy off the map, and be a great house clearer. Also, the same should be fixed on the 20mm AA, plus the 20mm AA should have that proximity expolsion too, as they did use proximity fuses on the ground 20mms.
Proximity fuse? On a 20mm? What the hell do you smoke?
A 20mm round has some g of explosives, even today adding in a proximity sensor there would be a delicate task, since the projectil is so tiny. And if you got your sensor and fuse in there, you don't need it anymore, since those shells have little more explosive power then china crackers. Of course they have some shrapnel, but with an explosive weight measured in single g, it won't really knock the house down (Handgrenades are around 100g)

Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori
Major Hartmann is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 1st, 2005   #7
I would die without GF
 
Anlushac11's Avatar
 
Join Date: April 28th, 2003
Location: Babylon 5
Status: Available
15,517 posts, 41 likes.
Rep Power: 0
Anlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexeh
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

IIRC Axis were never able to develop a effective proximity fused shell in WW2 anyways so no point in discussing how effective it would be.

I seem to remember a discussion on fused shells in regards to AA guns and it seems that 76mm was the smallest proximity fused shell used in WW2.

The 20mm rounds had good explosive power if they hit, but no proximity fuses.
Anlushac11 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 1st, 2005   #8
Captain
 
Cap.Miller's Avatar
 
Join Date: January 17th, 2005
Location: Germany - Dortmund
Status: Available
722 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 0
Cap.Miller has disabled reputation
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

lol a 20mm round at the feets won't kill any soldier.
It would probably blow the feets and maybe the a part of the legs away.
So it should just take 1/3 damage if you shoot there...


Greatings Cap.Miller/Avatar and sig made by NCOL
Cap.Miller is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 1st, 2005   #9
Peo
The forums staffers think I'm Cool
 
Join Date: April 28th, 2003
Location: Malmö, Sweden
Status: Available
184 posts, 0 likes.
Rep Power: 0
Peo is a n00b
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

A 20mm shell wouldn't even blow up the persons feet. It contains very little explosives and they are small so they don't make much in the way of shrapnel.
The explosive of a 20mm is used to breach something, in this case the armour or hull of a aircraft to make a slightly bigger hole than a MG would. To kill a person you would have to hit them directly.

As for proximity fuses, they were hardly used at all in ww2. Most realistic is to not have them at all.
Peo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old February 1st, 2005   #10
I would die without GF
 
Anlushac11's Avatar
 
Join Date: April 28th, 2003
Location: Babylon 5
Status: Available
15,517 posts, 41 likes.
Rep Power: 0
Anlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexehAnlushac11 is dead sexeh
Default Re: 20mm shell needs some power.

The US and Allies did not sue proximity fuses in ETO or MTO for fear of a unexploded shell falling into enemy hands. In the PTO most AA guns were firing over water so if a shell didnt explode it just fell into the water.

By fall of 1944 when it was obvious that the Allies would win proximity shells were introduced into ETO and MTO.

The proximity fuses were mostly used on 105mm and 155mm howitzers. There werent many Luftwaffe targets by fall of 1944 so proximity fused AA shells were not a priority.
Anlushac11 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
20mm? Necrid General Yib-Yab (Off Topic) 4 May 3rd, 2004 07:57 PM


All times are GMT -7.







   
 





This site is part of the Defy Media Gaming network

The best serving of video game culture, since 2001. Whether you're looking for news, reviews, walkthroughs, or the biggest collection of PC gaming files on the planet, Game Front has you covered. We also make no illusions about gaming: it's supposed to be fun. Browse gaming galleries, humor lists, and honest, short-form reporting. Game on!

FileFront Forums - Terms of Service - Top
Theme Selection
Copyright © 2002-2016 Game Front. All rights reserved. Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Forum Theme by Danny King (FileTrekker), Sheepeep & Graeme(rs)
RSS Feed Widget by FeedWind