FileFront Forums

FileFront Forums (http://forums.filefront.com/)
-   FH Off Topic (http://forums.filefront.com/fh-off-topic-579/)
-   -   Your role in WW2. (http://forums.filefront.com/fh-off-topic/268321-your-role-ww2.html)

Toekar July 30th, 2006 04:46 PM

Your role in WW2.
 
You are a civilian in any country you choose in the WW2 era, and must join the war. IF you had the choice, what would your job be? What country? Any specifics such as unit, battles and so on.

oscar989 July 30th, 2006 04:52 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Since my Grandfather came from Italy after WWII, then my choice for what country I would be fighting for would be Italy. I would want to join the paratroops, I would most likely want to join the 'Nembo' or the 'Folgore'. If it was 1940 or before, then I would have to join the Lybian Colonial Paratroopers. Meaning I would have fought at Derna and would have fought as a rear-gaurd for the 10th army after Op. compass. If I joined 'Folgore' 'Nembo', well you all know where they fought most notably. I would settle for a regular rifleman, but would prefer to have an SMG because of that Bretta 38. But I would NOT want to be a LMG member because than I would have to man that god awful Breda 30.

Gauntlet July 30th, 2006 05:07 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Fighting with claws and teeths for Norway! When we after many months of bitter fighting will have to capitulate, I'll hitch a ride with a fisherman over to the UK to continue the fighter from there. Favourite role would have to be a fighter pilot flying Spits for the 331 Sqd. (No) of the 2nd Tactical Air Force.

Bikewer July 30th, 2006 05:42 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I read about a comic-book artist who got fired up with patriotism about 1942 and ran off to enlist. The army put him to work....Drawing comic books. He did "instructional" books and things meant to fire up the troops.

Sounds like as good a way to pass a war as any....

[21Pz]Stauffenberg July 30th, 2006 06:08 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I'd either be in a Tiger in Italy, or an Adjutant for my Grandmothers Grandfather, Kommandant von Paris, General Dietrich von Choltitz...

Lupin July 30th, 2006 06:19 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Well lets see.

I couldnt/wouldnt join the German army because 1: They lost and 2: I'm circumcised.
I wouldnt join Russia because being worthless cannon fodder isnt fun.
I wouldnt join Japan because I don't agree with their ideals. But if I did agree with their ideals, I would proabably be an ohka pilot or some other kamikazi. Dead serious.
I would probably join America as a sniper.
I might join Finland as infantry (or a tanker) because Finland is awesome.
I would probably join the Polish army as a 7tp tanker.

[21Pz]Stauffenberg July 30th, 2006 06:20 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
7tp tanker? That's not much better than beeing russian, is it? :p

Lupin July 30th, 2006 06:21 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by [21Pz]Stauffenberg
7tp tanker? That's not much better than beeing russian, is it? :p

Yeah, but it works great against panzer IIs. :D

Gauntlet July 30th, 2006 06:30 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
In FH, that is... ;)

pvt. Allen July 30th, 2006 06:30 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I would definately like to be in England and later take part in invasion of Normandy as a paratrooper. Hard to choose though if British or American, Brits had great country, planning and accent while Amies got great area for their operations.:D

[21Pz]Stauffenberg July 30th, 2006 06:53 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Also beeing stationed as a german troop in Sweden/norway would be nice, all they basicly suffered from was the strange day/night circling...
In fact, Germany lost more soldiers there that went into psychological treatment, than against the enemy or the resistance :p

foodmaniac2003 July 30th, 2006 06:54 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Id like to be a POW in America! :-D

Or Japanese, and i'd get two katanas and an emergency suicide bomb

But seriously, id like to be a Volkstrumm member, not only am I old enough, but the idea of resistance defending against amazing odds no matter how horrible the situation is just puts me in awe.

Gauntlet July 30th, 2006 07:08 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by [21Pz]Stauffenberg
Also beeing stationed as a german troop in Sweden/norway would be nice, all they basicly suffered from was the strange day/night circling...
In fact, Germany lost more soldiers there that went into psychological treatment, than against the enemy or the resistance :p

Hehehe. True.
I belive a number between 200000-300000 lucky German soldiers were stationed there right to the end of the war. Waiting for an invasion that never came...

Quote:

Originally Posted by foodmaniac2003
But seriously, id like to be a Volkstrumm member, not only am I old enough, but the idea of resistance defending against amazing odds no matter how horrible the situation is just puts me in awe.

You'll be dead before supper-time, kiddo.

Oberst.Voss|13Pz| July 30th, 2006 07:42 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Devils brigade (1st Special Service Force), a Canadian-American commando unit fighting alongside each other in Italy (Naples, Foggia, Anzion, Rome-Arno) during 1943-44. Hilltop hopping basicly, taking out German fortifications. Devils Brigade, especially the Canadians of Devils brigade were known for leaving notes attatched to German corpses by knife for the enemy to find to demoralize the enemy. A truly great force.

[130pz.]Kading July 30th, 2006 08:02 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
i'd do what my grandpappy did: stateside navy recruiter! :naughty:





in all seriousness, artillery or anti aircraft gunner.

foodmaniac2003 July 30th, 2006 08:04 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gauntlet
You'll be dead before supper-time, kiddo.

My trusty panzerfausts will kill those ruskies! :-D

My string of thought is practically the same. I think of tank-hunting as a game of hide and go seek combined with elements of tag.

They need to give the panzerfaust kit an MP40...

oscar989 July 30th, 2006 08:05 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I have not been to war, but I am smart enough to know know that comparing war to a game will get you killed in a second.

Oberst.Voss|13Pz| July 30th, 2006 08:06 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Dr.Goebbels would send your Volkssturm unit headlong into a giant russian advance, misinformed, undergunned and under fire. Volkssturm was a death sentence but none the less a noble cause which i would fight in to defend my country if my country needed it. Canada all the way bitches.

foodmaniac2003 July 30th, 2006 08:08 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by oscar989
I have not been to war, but I am smart enough to know know that comparing war to a game will get you killed in a second.

I realise that, but Hitler Youth really did think of tank-hunting as a game, and strangly were very successful.

No, do not think of me as an immature little trigger happy child who just wants to go to war to shoot people. Ive read enough books (thick books, not picture ones!) and I know its horrors.

Mr.Panzerschrek July 30th, 2006 08:09 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I woulda joined Princess Patricias Canadian Light Infantry (who are currently serving in afghanistan) or Lord Strathcona's horse (tank), or maybe been an AA gunner in the royal navy like my grandpa was :D

zuiquan1 July 30th, 2006 08:15 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I would never want to be involved in a war like WW2, the horrors those men had to go through is aw-inspiring, I could never face anything like that. I salute every single one of them, from every country, good and bad for what they went through

gatordh7 July 30th, 2006 08:58 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
i'm sure if any of you actualy knew what war is like, you would just sign up as army cooks lol

Johannes July 30th, 2006 09:05 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by [21Pz]Stauffenberg
I'd either be in a Tiger in Italy, or an Adjutant for my Grandmothers Grandfather, Kommandant von Paris, General Dietrich von Choltitz...

Wow.

Wow because I'd join the Free French Army as a rifleman in order to help liberate France. I'd like to be a part of the French Expeditionary Corps in Italy, but then transfered to the French 2nd Armored to take part in the liberation of Paris. And if I had knowledge that I was from the future (meaning I somehow went back in time to participate), I'd try to squeeze my way through and get an autograph of Dietrich von Choltitz! (Hey, guy helped save Paris in a way.)

Of course, this was only supposing I had to join an army, since knowing me I probably wouldn't do so voluntarily.

Fuzzy Bunny July 30th, 2006 10:16 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I'd be Monsieur Rick. Yossarian can be Captain Renault.

Or either Private Kelly or Sgt. Oddball, plotting to make off with Nazi millions.

Oh, real people you say?

How about "Wild Bill" Donovan, coming up with crackpot ideas to assassinate Nazi thugs on the toilet.

Or Francis "Gabby" Gabreski, knocking down the hun, one at a time.

Or maybe this guy:

http://images.google.com/images?q=tb....%25201945.jpg

I always liked his style, especially the pearl-handled .45s. And putting paid to legions of pantz0r whores is always a Good Thing. Or how about Dugout Doug (same thing, snappy dresser, and love the pipe):

http://images.google.com/images?q=tb..._macarthur.jpg

Can't say I'd go for the Russians/Japanese/Italians/Germans (don't like totalitarian regimes much, especially LOSER ones), or the British or French (too snooty.)

[130pz.]Kading July 30th, 2006 10:27 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FuzzyBunny
I always liked his style, especially the pearl-handled .45s.


they were ivory, he once stated that only a cheap New Orleans pimp carries a pearl-handled gun. also, one of them was a .45 and the other was (dont hold me to this) a nickle plated and ivory grip colt peacemaker.

Braun July 30th, 2006 10:36 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gatordh7
i'm sure if any of you actualy knew what war is like, you would just sign up as army cooks lol

I'm sure if you actually noticed that this was for fun you wouldn't make smart-ass comments. :D

Ontopic: I would definately be an RCAF pilot, either spit or lancaster like my grandpapa. If not I would be a German Tiger commander.

Jetro July 30th, 2006 10:43 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Throw me in with the 761st Tank Battalion:D.

The '40s wouldn't have alot of exciting war options open for me.:(

Fuzzy Bunny July 30th, 2006 10:46 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by [130pz.]Kading
they were ivory, he once stated that only a cheap New Orleans pimp carries a pearl-handled gun. also, one of them was a .45 and the other was (dont hold me to this) a nickle plated and ivory grip colt peacemaker.

Whatever, you anal-retentive killjoy pedant nitpicker. Anyone that runs around in a silver helmet and jodhpurs, wiping out the armored boche hordes, is O-tay in my book.

And what's wrong with New Orleans pimps? Neither the Germans nor the Japanese had any New Orleans pimps on their side, and look at what happened to them.

DivS-Wuttke July 30th, 2006 11:09 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
It's insane to discuss about where, when and how you would have liked to fight. We should be happy that we do not have to experience war at all!

DerMann July 30th, 2006 11:16 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I'd like to be a resistance fighter in France, mainly because being sneaky, shooting Germans in the back with single shot pistols, and helping shot down pilots reach safety is definately my thing.

Or I'd like to be Sean Connery in "A Bridge Too Far", and carry a Webley,

As foodmaniac said, fighting against overwhelming odds can be fun, however, only if you're fighting zombies (the zombies I'm referring to are from "The Zombie Survival Handbook", none of this Half-Life stuff, just regular stupid, slow moving zombies, like in Shawn of the Dead).

Toekar July 30th, 2006 11:50 PM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DivS-Wuttke
It's insane to discuss about where, when and how you would have liked to fight. We should be happy that we do not have to experience war at all!

Of course, this is more fantasy then actual war. As for myself, since my family was in Germany at the time, sign me up for MG-Schütze in the Wehrmacht. I prefer to keep my ass on the ground.

gatordh7 July 31st, 2006 12:27 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DerMann
shooting Germans in the back with single shot pistols

lol wow so much for honour

Seth_Soldier July 31st, 2006 02:44 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gatordh7
lol wow so much for honour

at least he will be able to kill more german officer than any enlisted soldier ! :naughty:

Knoffhoff July 31st, 2006 02:58 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
I'd offer some NSDAP fat cat to herd his sheep for free, if he takes care that I don't have to go to war. ;)

Pornska July 31st, 2006 03:27 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Probably a Tankette TKS commander :evilgrin:

Ph34r me!

Meadow July 31st, 2006 03:35 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
There's a tough one. In seriousness, I wouldn't mind commanding a mobile artillery battery in Italy - great landscape, and you're actually doing fighting without much risk of dying (counter battery fire and air attack noted). In a fantasy where I couldn't die, I certainly wouldn't mind being a British infantryman fighting my way through Caen with a Sten or SMLE.

Of course, if this were the real thing, back then I'd either have been in Malta, England or Denmark - the first one I'd probably get a job at the docks like my grandfather, either find myself pulled into the PBI in Portsmouth or into the Navy for the second one, and probably sat tight with my family in Denmark. Might've delivered resistance newspapers like my great grandfather, but I'm not much of the type to go blowing up railway lines.

EDIT: Nearly forgot - at least one ride in a Lancaster during a night time raid would be sweet as heck. Assuming we didn't eat FlaK.

Gauntlet July 31st, 2006 03:49 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foodmaniac2003
I realise that, but Hitler Youth really did think of tank-hunting as a game, and strangly were very successful.

Oh please...they were nowhere near what I would call successful. I wouldnt call killing one T-34 in exchange for twenty 12-15 year olds succsessful. The Volksturm, and Hitlerjugend units sent to war was mostly KIA or even worse.

In real life, you dont get to respawn...

Quote:

No, do not think of me as an immature little trigger happy child who just wants to go to war to shoot people. Ive read enough books (thick books, not picture ones!) and I know its horrors.
We can't realy understand war just by reading about it from books.

Cap'n Rommel July 31st, 2006 03:58 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
If I had a choice I would be German stationed in DK, the whip cream front

Big Lebowski July 31st, 2006 04:03 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
hehe exactly my thoughts too. great documentary (whip cream front), some of those german soldiers really loved denmark.
apperently the best place you could be in ww2

but if i have to be a bit patriotic i guess i would have joined the danish resistance like my grandfather

Pornska July 31st, 2006 04:06 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Big LeBowSki
apperently the best place you could be in ww2

That, or Switzerland and Sweden :)

Big Lebowski July 31st, 2006 04:08 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

apperently the best place you could be in ww2
well for a german soldiers that is.

Cap'n Rommel July 31st, 2006 04:25 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Big LeBowSki
hehe exactly my thoughts too. great documentary (whip cream front), some of those german soldiers really loved denmark.
apperently the best place you could be in ww2

but if i have to be a bit patriotic i guess i would have joined the danish resistance like my grandfather

yes, if I had to be patriotic I would join the resistance too, or just keep myself out of everything

[11PzG]matyast July 31st, 2006 04:47 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Hungarian infantry/pilot....

Reality:
-No pilot license due to sight
-skill wise tailgunner to a Stuka :(

RexRaptor July 31st, 2006 05:04 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Captured Nazi scientist Dr. Merkwürdigeliebe...if any of you get that, you get a brownie.

Cap'n Rommel July 31st, 2006 05:09 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
^captured by the russians, after conducting experiments on russian pows

snotvod July 31st, 2006 06:14 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RexRaptor
Captured Nazi scientist Dr. Merkwürdigeliebe...if any of you get that, you get a brownie.

It's dr Strangelove!! Ooh, gimme a brownie.:D

Seriously now, if i was born in the early 1920's, i would either be a gunner on a T.13BIII tankhunter (sig) in the "tweede lanciers" armoured division of the Belgian army, or a infantryman, armed with an m89, m36, or an fm30, in the "eerste linie" division. After the wise decision of our Dear King Leopold III, to surrender to the Germans, I will go to a POW camp in Poland. Then i will overtake the camp with some fellow Belgians and Dutchies and escape to Spain through Switzerland. When i get to England with a rubber boat, I will enlist to join the Brigade Piron, in which i shall fight the German oppressor till the bitter end, his or mine ;)

RexRaptor July 31st, 2006 06:18 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by snotvod
It's dr Strangelove!! Ooh, gimme a brownie.:D

Seriously now, if i was born in the early 1920's, i would either be a gunner on a T.13BIII tankhunter (sig) in the "tweede lanciers" armoured division of the Belgian army, or a infantryman, armed with an m89, m36, or an fm30, in the "eerste linie" division. After the wise decision of our Dear King Leopold III, to surrender to the Germans, I will go to a POW camp in Poland. Then i will overtake the camp with some fellow Belgians and Dutchies and escape to Spain through Switzerland. When i get to England with a rubber boat, I will enlist to join the Brigade Piron, in which i shall fight the German oppressor till the bitter end, his or mine ;)

<.<...I ate the brownie, I didn't expect anyone to get it...>.>...*stops right hand from strangling him*

General Rommel July 31st, 2006 06:25 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zuiquan1
I would never want to be involved in a war like WW2, the horrors those men had to go through is aw-inspiring, I could never face anything like that. I salute every single one of them, from every country, good and bad for what they went through

Sir, I agree with you 100% Anywayz ignoring that he said I would go with the 2nd Infantry Division Rangers. Or the 1st British Airborne... UGHH its such a hard choice :( SOMEONE HOLD ME!

DerMann July 31st, 2006 07:56 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gatordh7
lol wow so much for honour

Well, I'd yell some French taunt (graciously provided by Monty Python and the Holy Grail) and as he turns around, pop him in the face with my Liberator.

How's that for honour :P

Fuzzy Bunny July 31st, 2006 08:06 AM

Re: Your role in WW2.
 
<THREAD HIJACK!>

Screw Liberators. They shoulda just cranked up mass production of Mossberg 12-gauges and air dropped those over occupied Europe. So you want to knock fear into the heart of some nazi thug because he'll never know if Monsieur Pierre is packing? Well imagine that if he was likely to have a pump-action large caliber shotgun instead of some little dinky one-shot popgun!

Just insert that gratuitous *kerr-chikk* BOOM! into any number of WWII movies. Like Tom Hanks potting away at the Panzer with his .45:

Panzer: rumble rumble rumble
Tom Hanks: *kerr-chikk* BOOM!

OK, he still would have died, but it would have been a lot cooler.

Or Vassili Zaitsev: "With your permission, comrade commissar" *kerr-chikk* BOOM! *kerr-chikk* BOOM! *kerr-chikk* BOOM! *kerr-chikk* BOOM! *kerr-chikk* BOOM! as another one bites the dust.

Or poor little Anne Frank, huddled in her attic, waiting for the goons to arrive. No more of this passive fatalism. Instead,

Nazi thug: "OPEN UP! IN ZE NAME OF ZE FUHRER!" *bangs down door*
Anne Frank: *kerr-chikk* BOOM! "Hah, take that you miserable hun!"

Or Col. Stauffenberg, in the Wolfsschanze. Screw bombs, just imagine a meeting room, from the outside.

Hitler: "But, vhat are you doink, Stauffenberg? Put zat awa.."
*kerr-chikk* BOOM! *kerr-chikk* BOOM! ...etc...as the windows light up from the inside with a series of loud, resounding large-caliber explosions.

Or do you think the Allies would have suffered such losses at D-Day if they'd all been armed with 12-gauges? Probably not, and the sound effects would have been far more gratifying.

And the German war machine wouldn't have gotten more than 300 meters inside of Belgium or Poland if it had been confronted with entire populations of shotgun-wielding farmers. No part of the world would have lived under tyranny and fear, thanks to the knowledge that at any moment, air-dropped pallets full of 12-gauge goodness would drop from the skies in the name of freedom.

http://www.militaryfactory.com/small...ossberg590.jpg

Remember kids, an armed society is a polite society.


All times are GMT -7.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.