Darth Revan versus Darth Vader

[Ihaterednecks]

Originally Posted by Revan91

And how does Vader being so badass have anything to do with his skills in combat? This thread reflects not only the thoughts of what these people have said, but also possibly what everyone else thinks as well. More people voted Revan than Vader. To be honest, I didn't vote at all because I believe they're evenly matched. If the two of them were ever in a tactical battle involving fleets of warships, Revan would win. That is just fact. Vader simply has practically no experience as a military commander. But as for skills with a lightsaber, I really don't know who would win. Vader would be extremely powerful if he wasn't crippled, which is the situation I liked to put them in in the first place.

Also, if you're talking in terms of BADASSness, crippled Vader wears black cybernetic armor, and a big-ass life support system on his chest that might as well say "SHOOT ME HERE". Uncrippled Vader would most likely simply had a black robe and tunic. Revan comes with all of it: Awesome cape, cool robes, the hood just looks awesome, and the mask, need I say more?
Revan is badass. Vader is also definitely badass, I'll admit, but Revan is more.

Vader's awesomeness radiates from him in so much intensity that it destroys his body. Seriously, compare Vader to Revan in appearance. Revan's mask looks like shit, Vader looks like a Samurai. If you say Revan is more badass than Vader, your opinion must have been put through a fucking meat grinder, AKA, you played KOTOR a few to many times. Game developers can just rip the PC to the point of godhood. Moviemakers have limits. If Vader was portayed in a game originally, he would wade through shit like it was butter, because that's how game's work. A single individual wiping out hundreds of grunts. The following lore had to be based around it, or it would be inconsistent and stupid. I speak out of compassion of a fan of the movies, I am the voice of the common man.

[The Crusader]

Originally Posted by Ihaterednecks

Vader's awesomeness radiates from him in so much intensity that it destroys his body. Seriously, compare Vader to Revan in appearance. Revan's mask looks like shit, Vader looks like a Samurai. If you say Revan is more badass than Vader, your opinion must have been put through a fucking meat grinder, AKA, you played KOTOR a few to many times. Game developers can just rip the PC to the point of godhood. Moviemakers have limits. If Vader was portayed in a game originally, he would wade through shit like it was butter, because that's how game's work. A single individual wiping out hundreds of grunts. The following lore had to be based around it, or it would be inconsistent and stupid. I speak out of compassion of a fan of the movies, I am the voice of the common man.

This thread wasn't about who was more badass. It was about who would win. Your only opinion so far in this thread is that Vader would win because he is badass. You tell me, how the hell does that prove anything?

[Lordjedi]

Originally Posted by Phildevil

Geez, is it possible to read the first post of the topic? Perhaps only the previous one. It has clearly been said that this poll was comparing Revan (if he'd survived the 4 000 years and is still top shape) and Vader UNCORRUPTED and NOT WEAKENED by any life support armor. And he IS very powerful. You say he's weak? But in the end, he defeated Windu, scared Yoda(who went into exile), defeated plenty of Jedi(not only children, but also full grown Jedi, uh, JCarter!), defeated Darth Maul's clone, defeated any opponent that has opposed him(except his son), including Xizor, who was very powerful too. Oh, and just think about how easely he defeated Dooku in Ep III. And he was not even at his best. So stop to tell stupid things as he's weak and sissy. Vader is THE most hated person in the galaxy, and it ain't for nothin'.

He did not defeated Windu Sidiuos did .Defeating Dooku yeah hmm 1.Dookus old 2.Vader did not defeat him Anakin did when Anakin first fell the the darkside he was hella power no one could stop he when he became Vader he sucked.Also Look what Revan has Down,He defeated Mandalore the Ulitmate and ended a war single handedly,Defeated many Mandos,Learned the teachings of the Darkside and learned more knowledge and became more powerful to destory the True Sith to save the republic,Killed many Jedi during the Jedi Civil War,Trained a great appertice Malak who were Vaders appertices some weak Dark Jedi,Found 5 Star Maps and found the star forge,Manipulated many jedi easily broke them and turned them to the Dark Side,A natural leader,Defeated Bastila Shan (If Lightside on the star forge and decide to kill her which I dont )Defeated Darth Malak,And defeated the Dark Side!!!And Revan was Never the appertice he was the master unlike Vader and was the so stupid to belive someone and turn you to the dark side

[Lordjedi]

Originally Posted by Ihaterednecks

Vader's awesomeness radiates from him in so much intensity that it destroys his body. Seriously, compare Vader to Revan in appearance. Revan's mask looks like shit, Vader looks like a Samurai. If you say Revan is more badass than Vader, your opinion must have been put through a fucking meat grinder

You must be drunk to say that Vader is bad!!!!!!!! Revan's Mask is awesome

[Ihaterednecks]

How about this. I like both of the masks. Vader's is just cooler.

Originally Posted by Revan91

This thread wasn't about who was more badass. It was about who would win. Your only opinion so far in this thread is that Vader would win because he is badass. You tell me, how the hell does that prove anything?

I'm just screwing around. Chill the fuck out, foo'.

[The Crusader]

C? now wasn't that easier to say? jejeje

[Phildevil]

@ LordJedi25 or so...

Windu would have killed Palpatine, but ANAKIN was there and HE made it that Windu did not win. Otherwise, Windu WOULD have win. So don't twist my words, Anakin's apperance was the turning of the combat. For Dooku, I don't fuckin' care how old he is, he was still defeated by Anakin(now don't tell me Vader isn't Anakin, or do take any lesson. The fact is that they are the same person.). Vader's apprentice ain't weak: he made an Imperial Star Destroyer fell on a planet. Anyway, I could debate with you during ages and I would never convince you and yoiu wouldn't either, so, lets just drop-it, we ain't going anywhere...

[Ihaterednecks]

A possible subconscious influence?

Thing with Revan's mask, it doesn't have much of a shape. It's a rectangle. A blob. Vader's mask has a more defined form, it's more angular and intimidating, not a brown rectangle (Basically) with a visor.

[The Crusader]

Originally Posted by Ihaterednecks

A possible subconscious influence?

Thing with Revan's mask, it doesn't have much of a shape. It's a rectangle. A blob. Vader's mask has a more defined form, it's more angular and intimidating, not a brown rectangle (Basically) with a visor.

Yeah, in game Revan's mask looks sort of like it's been forced there, or glued there. The main thing I don't think I like about Vader is the helmet though. I mean, he wasn't an imperial officer, so why did he have the officer's helmet? His eye pieces seemed kind of big too, but the mask itself is more symmetrical than Revan's.

[Lordjedi]

Good posting Revan91 I agree with you.